Mumme Poll – Week 7, Plus Mid-Season Grades on the Team

Here’s the new poll, based on your voting.

Falling out of the poll this week: Arizona State (23), Illinois (19), Michigan (18)

So how did we Refugees rate the team at the midpoint of the season?

Quarterback – Solid B – 90.9% of you rated the QB room a B. I guess I could’ve asked for context, but given most of the banter here, I’d say most of us are happy with Stockton’s play (haven’t seen people ranting for Pug to start over him), but would like to see more in the passing game especially with extending the field. It’s hard to argue with the Rabun County Superman, though, as he’s definitely the leader of the offense and doesn’t hesitate to put the team on his back, when needed.

Running Backs – Solid B – 83.3% – Definitely nice to see depth in the RB room again. Between Frazier, Bowens, and McRae, all the makings for a Manball revival are there at RBU agian.

Offensive Line – C+ – A little over half of you rated the OL a C, and around 30% rated it a B, so I’ll go with C+. The unit has started to come to gel more in recent weeks, but considering we saw the sixth offensive line configuration in six games on the Plains, they are doing a workman-like job. Getting all together, for four quarters and sticking together (and staying healthy) can move this group into the B category sooner than later.

Receiving Room – B- – Majority vote here was a B, but I think similar to the QB rating, we’d like to see more of a downfield game and more touches by the tight ends and Noah Thomas. Stretching the field and seeing these five star TEs becoming receiving weapons would be a nice touch for the second half of the season.

Defensive Line – C – Do I need to elaborate on this one? The group does a good job stuffing the run and clogging the interior, but the lack of a major backfield disruptor is keeping the group bogged down from creating havoc like we saw in 2021 and 2022.

Linebackers – B – Solid group, tackling is way improved, but same as the defensive line, we’re not seeing enough backfield stops and sacks for this group to be in the a category. Though they did save our tails Saturday, no?

Secondary – C- – I’d argue that if the two above did their jobs a touch better, this group would look better, as well. Youth and some very visible miscues seems to make this unit the redheaded stepchild of the Georgia defense.

Special Teams – A – This is a no doubter. Quick question – aside from Saturday, when’s the last time you saw Woodring miss a field goal? Or when Thorson booted a poor punt? And our coverage units are definitely on the mother this year.

Tune in next week for the next Mumme Poll…I’ll make sure to include coaches as part of next week’s ratings!

Week 6 Mumme Poll Results – Step Away From the Twin, Carson

Week 6 reveals we have a new number one.

Also receiving votes: Auburn, Mississippi State, TCU, Florida State, all with 4 votes each. I could’ve put Auburn in as a 25 tied with these four, but I’m not ranking Auburn in top 25 of anything good.

Dropping out: Texas (11), Penn State (14), Florida State (16), Mississippi State (20)

Regarding the bonus question – which undefeated teams are most likely to appear in the national championship game:

Miami – 77%

Ohio State – 70%

Oregon – 40%

Ole Miss – 5%

Texas A&M – 4%

Oklahoma – 5%

Can Miami keep it going? How couldn’t they? They have a Charmin soft schedule for the rest of the season, get the ACC Championship against Tech or Virginia, and should get past those…but…but…growing rumor in South Beach is that Beck is back with the Cavinder twin…unleash the interceptions!

Week 6 Mumme Poll – Deep in the Fart of Texas Edition

The AP poll decided to drop State Penn and Texass completely out of the poll this week, being that neither have beaten a P4 team to date. The Coaches, on the other hand, felt Franklin and Sarkisian still have potential. Doesn’t matter, because we all know the only poll that matters.

MASH HERE

Is Texas poised to be the next Alabama? Yes. Alabama-Birmingham, perhaps.

Voting closes tomorrow at noon. Bonus question – which currently undefeated teams do you see most likely being in the National Championship game?

Mumme Poll Week 5 – Brian, James, and Lincoln Walk Into a Bar

Here’s the results from Week 5.

Also receiving votes: Louisville, USC, BYU

Dropping out of the poll: USC (19), TCU (22), Syracuse (24), Memphis (25), Houston (25)

Well, I can’t throw too much snark at Kelly, Riley, or Franklin, as Smart just laid his usual egg against Alabama, but it’s safe to say we all called it here that Penn State was vastly overrated. Despite a furious comeback at the end against the Illini, Riley has now been once again relegated to just a great West Coast recruiter, and to make matters worse for Brian Kelly, Nussmeier is now out for the year, or at least those were the initial rumors that Kelly is dispelling. Regardless, he is injured, and that ain’t helping the Bayou Bengals.

Look at Virginia! The Senator would be proud.

Regarding the SECCG poll (will Georgia make the SECCG)

  1. Probably not, but stranger things have happened – 52%
  2. I’m Thinking It’s Likely – 40%
  3. Confident No – 8%
  4. Confident Yes – 4%

Contrary to the AP poll, where Georgia plummeted 7 spots behind Alabama (of course) and Penn State only dropped five, I’d say there’s a happy balance between the Mumme and the “ball knowers” Poll. Like many of you, I can’t call us a Top 5 or Top 10 team…do we have the potential to be? Yes. My Yorkie also has the potential to be a Pit Bull…but I’d have to see it actually bite more than it barks. I remain hopeful, yet comfortably Munson at the same time.

Until next week!

Week 4 Mumme Poll Results – Look at the Big Brain on Bret!

The results are in.

Also receiving votes: Louisville, Auburn, South Florida. Falling out: Illinois (previously 16th), Utah (18th), South Florida (24th).

How do we compare to the AP?

Personally, I feel like the Mumme Poll better ranks TAMU and Texas than does the AP, along with Iowa State. Penn State is going to have to prove something this weekend, but I also feel like the AP has the Nittany Liars too high. Clearly a little Georgia bias is in play here for Dan Lanning and Fran Brown, and how Illinois and Notre Dame has a ranking after the Irish are 1-2 and Illinois got curb stomped by the Hoosiers is a little surprising, but our crew gave some grace to the G5 teams and allowed Memphis and Houston into the Top 25.

Also, a word about Missouri…have you watched them play yet? They have one of the best running backs in the league, imo, in Ahmad Hardy. 600 yards rushing, 6 TDs, and 7.6 yards per touch. Holy cow, just sayin’.

***Update – Napier fate poll results***

Regarding the fate of the head Lizard in charge (when will Napier get fired?):

  1. 35.4% – After two more losses, including a loss to Georgia
  2. 24.6% – End of Season
  3. 16.9% – After the next loss to Texas
  4. 13.4% – They’ll give him an extension…hopefully
  5. 9.8% – Possibly today

Hey, they fired Gundy on a Tuesday…you never know.

Week 3 Mumme Poll – Suck of the Irish

I’m becoming convinced that the only poll that ever matters is our own Mumme Poll. Danny Kanell went on a tirade last week and called out several pollsters, including one from the AP that justified ranking Florida ahead of USF on their poll. That looks more hilariously poor after DJ’s showering of interceptions to the Tigers.

What I’m not getting is all the love for USC, and why people continue to rank Notre Dame. I get it…two losses to two good teams. Sure. But the only game they have left on their schedule that’s worth a damn is…USC. Looks like they’re justifying any way they can to sneak the Irish back into the CFP. What’s worse, the computer-based polling doesn’t look much better right now.

Imagine what it must feel like to be a Tech fan and see the FPI. Anyway, on to this week’s Mumme Poll.

Tech fans would love our poll, no? Dropping out of the Mumme Poll this week – the state of South Carolina and Notre Dame. Damn straight.

Also, some of us are feeling a little more optimistic this week about our chances for the rest of the season (how many games will we lose this season):

  1. One game – 40%
  2. Two games – 25%
  3. Undefeated – 20%
  4. Three games – 5%

Question – for those of you who selected one or two games…who do you see on the schedule as a possible loss? I’m not liking Alabama getting their offensive groove back, and until our front seven can demonstrate consistent pressure in the backfield, I’m worried that that would be our one. I’m still concerned about Ole Miss, and Texas is looking less and less concerning by the week. Then, there’s Tech…but as good as they’ve been, they’re so heavily reliant on Haynes King I’ve got to imagine that Kirby is planning weekly for that matchup like he used to do in preparation for Fish Fry’s option offenses.

What do you think?

Week Three Mumme Poll – Luck of the Irish Edition

In case you haven’t had a chance to peep the lunacy that is the AP Top 25 poll, check out a winless Notre Dame still lingering around the Top 25.

They’re ranked 24th, in case you don’t want to click. Georgia earns a Top 15 win, meanwhile Penn State hasn’t played a team with a pulse and sits at #2. Wins against Nevada, FIU, and perennial football powerhouse Villanova gets you that kind of clout.

Also, it’s looking more and more like Ohio State’s win against Texass and LSU’s win against Clemson is looking less and less impressive. What are the voters thinking? Are they thinking?

Anyway, prove them all wrong with the only poll that counts…vote today!

MASH HERE.

Voting closes tomorrow at noon.