I spent the weekend watching the Diamond Dawgs (swept USCe, by the way…Go Dawgs!) and the Braves, and all the rage on the socials was about the ABS overturns in Major League Baseball. The Automated Ball-Strike (ABS) System is a “robo-ump” that quickly measures up a hitter and gets a strike zone based on the hitter’s appropriate strike zone, and if the batter, catcher, or pitcher think a call didn’t go their way, they have two ABS challenges they can use by tapping their head.
If successful, you still have two challenges left. Some teams challenged away successfully multiple times. Some (like the Braves) blew their two in the first inning.
So far, the catchers have been the ones to use the robo ump the most, followed by batters, and least by pitchers. I guess they have to trust the catcher more since they have a better idea of the zone than does the pitcher.
Anyway, it seems to be making the game better, in some people’s opinions, and the purists are the ones having the hardest time with it as they believe there should be some of that umpire error involved. I’ve enjoyed it, so far, but the one thing about it is that the review is quick, a decision is made, and they move on.
What’s interesting in college football, on the other hand, is the length of reviews when they are used in a game, like for targeting or inbounds catches and so on. One thing I liked the few times I watched an ACC game, is that they transparently broadcast the review for all to hear:
Now I don’t think every play can be reviewed ad nauseum, but having more than one might be nice. You can currently challenge certain plays, by calling a timeout and requesting a challenge, and, if successful, can challenge again later.
What I don’t care for is that the following can’t be reviewed:
- Holding
- Pass Interference (remember the Texas game…I do, and you do, too)
- Illegal contact, block in the back, or roughing the passer
- Spot fouls for personal fouls, like facemasking
Would having more challenges improve the game? Also, would allowing challenges to the four categories above improve it, as well?
Discuss.