Some Things Don’t Transfer

Here’s an interesting graphic for you to chew on this morning.

Georgia took in the fewest transfers of all SEC teams, despite having 17 players transfer out. They currently have the best record in the SEC, as you well know.

Not surprisingly, the teams with the biggest movement, such as Auburn, that took in 39 transfers to match with their 39 transferring out, and LSU, which did the same, aren’t seeing the same return on investment that, say, Indiana got by having literally the entire JMU roster move with Cignetti when he got hired by Indiana.

What’s even more interesting is that many of the transfers that are coming in for some teams, like Arkansas, aren’t necessarily upgrades in personnel, just replacements. Arkansas took in 42 transfers, of which only 3 were four or five star athletes (7% of total transfers). Notably, Georgia’s 9 transfers had a four-star rate of 44%.

Ole Miss and LSU had the highest number of incoming four or five star transfers, which was likely needed with some of the loss to LSU when Lane went packing to the Bayou, but clearly they put all their eggs in two baskets – Chambliss and Lacy – just to see Lacy hurt and some fairly glaring gaps in other positions around the field. Maybe Lane really was on to something, and Pete isn’t. I couldn’t care less, because screw ’em, that’s why.

Goes to show that (a) the transfer portal isn’t the magic bullet some think it to be and (b) roster management and making wise investments into sustainable NIL deals with who you recruited out of high school can be a path to success, just like the old days.

Invest wisely.

8 thoughts on “Some Things Don’t Transfer”

  1. Agent McGarity would have used this as further proof no additional money was needed by the football team for anything.

  2. For now Kirby has the best approach but the forces of greed and dilution in the tournament may erode his ability to keep the kind of players he needs willing to be developed.

  3. Mizzu beiing so high is a little surprising. They didn’t have the staff turnover you see with the other schools at the top of the list.

  4. If I’m not reading the chart wrong, looks to me like LSU had 18 incoming 4/5 stars while Ole Miss had 10. If I’m right it just goes to show how poor of an ROI the tigers are getting.

Leave a Reply