Thus Spaketh the Committee: Week 11 Round 3

While I waited for Illinois-Duke shooty hoops to finish up, I guessed there wouldn’t be too much surprise in this week’s Committee manipulation ranking. Should ‘Bama drop after so many of their big wins dropped a game this week? Would Cignetti’s crustiness with the media influence a nudge upwards? Could Hunter Yurachek look less uncomfortable on TV? These are my lightly edited real-time observations of the reveal…Let’s find out what we found out together:

21-25 Okie, L’ville and FU back in the rankings, Sakerlina drops here at 21.

16-20: Boise St moves up into this group, KY drops back along with Houston, with Arizona making history rising 4 spots to 19 after a loss?

11-15: anOSU rises six spots to 14 due to the carnage, giddiness from Rece as they are only 3 spots from getting in! Ducks at 13; first team out at 12 is Texas Tech; 11 spot goes to Wake who is absolutely rolling opponents the last four weeks.

10: BYU hanging around, holds at 10

9: Dirtnecks* drop a spot

8: Hoosiers up one spot, minimal crustiness influence

7: Da U holds serve

6: Notre Dame drops 1…still ahead of the ‘Canes, so head-to-head means something this week, sort of

5: Texas up one spot with “more good wins than anyone else in football”

4: UCLA remains fourth, meaning…

3: Alabama, despite looking like doo-doo for a good chunk against Vandy, keeps the SEC bias whining alive for another week.

2: Utah, after a scare most of the country was in bed for, stays #2

1: Kirby & Co., with obligatory mention of “inexplicable loss to Awburn” while “crushing everybody in their path”.

Here’s the bracket as it stands:

I’ll take it, hope it holds up.

Now, for the highlights of His Uneasiness, Hunter Hisself:

On Bama/Indiana difference in opponents losing: Hoosier bye and Bama SOS helped Bama more. LSU letdown a credit to Bama.

On Tennessee: Committee high on UT. Indy win over USC better than UT road win over

Wake/Texas Tech: Rece skips over these 1-loss teams’ placement to salivate over 3-loss Oregon and anOSU. Hunter: definitely separation between these teams. OK, then.

They then talked about teams at the bottom, which is where I quit taking notes because ain’t nobody got time for that.

The background music playing (loudly) over this conversation was a tad overwrought, IMO

Go Dawgs.

*A good friend of mine and a DGD coined this term for Tennessee after working a few years after college in Nashville. He taught me how to properly hate the Volunteers.

11 thoughts on “Thus Spaketh the Committee: Week 11 Round 3”

  1. Love that bracket. I don’t trust these clowns not to be setting us up. Still expecting a last minute SEC elimination bracket next to an easy b10 glide bracket.

  2. Not much to quibble over with this one. I wouldn’t have Bama at 3 and think UCLA should the benefit of the doubt over a 2 loss team. However, this bracket actually gives the Bruins the more favorable matchup by getting the winner of Texas and BSU rather than a likely matchup with ND.

  3. Oregon and Ohio State moves up set up the committee to drop Wake out of the top 12 when they lose in the World’s Smallest Outdoor Cocktail Party.

    Would the committee possibly ignore head to head with the last spot and put anOSU above Nike U?

    Good post, sir.

  4. Yawn. Going to be even less interesting next year. I think this show is going to die a slow death as they go to 24 and will end up being a short bracketology show each week on ESPNU until the last one (the only one that matters).

  5. Who actually watches this thing? Better yet, who the hell is going to watch it next year? Just release the list and let the B1G whining commence

  6. Pain and misery was looking at that half country club cocktail party, half hooker outfit that the renowned genius HD was wearing.

    • Dingbat Dominatrix Dinich (Triple D) telling Rece he’s gonna like it. This show is a joke & vapid Triple D is the perfect host for such a meaningless production.

  7. It sucks because there is bias…even if it is mostly right.

    “mostly” ain’t good enough.

    A glaring example..

    Tennessee beat Alabama convincingly but is 6 spots behind them.

    Head to head ..used only when the committee wants it to count.

    I don’t care for either, but I believe Tennessee should be ranked ahead of the

    Gumps. And I bet you there were people on the committee that felt the same way and were ignored.

    I’ve been on committees here and there in my life. In almost every instance, the chairperson of the committee had his agenda and got his way. The rest of the members were there to rubber-stamp his agenda and desires. Committees are usually stacked with enough ignoramuses with limited knowledge of the subject, easily swayed by the professionally prepared “data” from the boss, to nod,'”yes, yes, yes” to pre-ordained proposels. Useful idiots (or sycophants..or both)

    I hereby propose a solution that makes too much sense to be considered.

    One way to make the selection process fair is to outsource it to a data analysis group in a far away land like Hungary or maybe Norway or India and let people with zero knowledge of college football and with zero preferences or prejudices load the results of every Division 1 game played in the current season without any reference to conference affiliation, reputation or geographic location of any schools ….. as data into a computer. Teams should be represented by something other than their name so there is no idea of what team “NX” or “BH” or “xx345” is…just to be sure.

    Keep the location and data group top secret so there can be no $henanigans from E$PN or wealthy boosters.

    We know that Herbie and Saban and a lot of other media people have used their influence in the past to screw our favorite team out of the BCS. There’s no reason to expect them to not meddle (and they have and do if only indirectly from their positions and voice in the sports media). There’s no reason to believe that some or most if not all of the good folks on the Committee have biases..just like I would have were I on it (you too). They’re human…some may be dumb and easily swayed.

    People can be goofy and the CFB Committee is exhibit A in proving it.

    Past goofiness is the most accurate prediction of future goofiness.

    Outsource the thing to a far away land with unbiased computer geeks..and get a fair result..not just mostly fair but completely fair.

  8. It is criminal that Bama is #3 which only proves the point…this is all controlled by the Disney mafia. FOX seethes but gets their share of the pie as does Notre Dame TV. This is a tv script not reality. The more invested one gets in what the rankings “should” be the further you are from grasping what’s really going on. It’s the controversy that gets eyeballs. The AP poll is imperfect but a better list doesn’t stir up interest anymore. The playoffs are an invitational nothing more. Be interesting and bring eyeballs and you’ll get voted in. Be a nobody with no back story and you’re out. I’d rather they go to the format like Heidi Klum’s fashion show where each team’s HC comes out and makes a 30 second pitch to a panel of celebrity judges. That would be wayyyy more entertaining and honest than this shit show. “One moment you’re in, the next you’re out!”*

    *Wife made me watch it. And Tim Gunn better host than Davis.

Leave a Reply